Twig created this listing from public information. It isn't managed by Isner Insurance Associates, Inc.. Is this your agency?
Claim it
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc., Independent insurance agency in Columbus, OH
Since 1959 · Licensed in OH
4.9(127)Isner Insurance is an insurance agency in Columbus, Ohio that helps individuals, families, and business owners compare coverage and cost. The agency says it makes insurance simple, shops multiple carriers, and serves the Columbus metro area and the entire state of Ohio.
Most quotes back the site describes quotes and service as quick and says the team will reach out to complete the coverage comparison
Contact info
Location & business hours
What do you need covered?

Hi, I'm Thomas, Principal Agent of Isner Insurance Associates, Inc.. A licensed agent on my team reviews every quote — usually the site describes quotes and service as quick and says the team will reach out to complete the coverage comparison. Meet Thomas →
Quick answer
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. at a glance
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. is an independent insurance agency in Columbus, OH, founded in 1959. It compares 9 carriers including Foremost Insurance, The Hartford Insurance and National General Insurance for homeowners, auto, umbrella and more. Customers rate it 4.9 out of 5 across 127 reviews.
- Founded
- 1959 · 67 years in business
- Agency type
- Independent — not tied to one insurance company
- Carriers compared
- 9 — Foremost Insurance, The Hartford Insurance, National General Insurance, …
- Coverage
- 19 lines — homeowners, auto, umbrella, condo, atv & powersports, …
- Licensed in
- OH
- Serving
- Columbus metro area, Ohio and Central Ohio
- Rating
- 4.9 out of 5 · 127 reviews
Getting a quote
How to get a quote from Isner Insurance Associates, Inc.
How it works
- 1Enter basic information on the website
- 2The agency compares multiple carriers
- 3Choose the coverage package you like best
What to have ready
- Basic contact information
- For personal quotes: requested policy types such as auto, home/condo, umbrella, specialty vehicle, rental property, or business insurance
- For business quotes: legal business name, DBA if applicable, preferred phone and email, requested coverages, desired effective date
No Social Security number needed to start.
Coverage we offer
Insurance coverage in Columbus, OH
Personal
Business
- General LiabilityCoverage for allegations of bodily injury or property damage against your business.
- Business PropertyHelping landlords and commercial real estate investors insure their buildings and habitation risks.
- Commercial AutoWith a wide selection of commercial auto carriers, the agency says it can find affordable coverage quickly.
- Commercial UmbrellaCan help protect a business from devastating claims arising from an unforeseen event.
- Cyber LiabilityCovers data breaches, ransomware, phishing attacks, and regulatory fines.
- Professional LiabilityDescribed as a critical coverage that is a staple of a solid commercial package.
- BondsOffers a full range of commercial bonds, including surety bonds and performance bonds.
- ContractorsHelps contractors and other tradesmen protect their business operations.
- Business Package
- Workers CompensationProtecting employees is protecting the business.
- Businesses we insure
- Small businesses, Contractors, Landlords, Commercial real estate investors
- Carriers
- Foremost Insurance, The Hartford Insurance, National General Insurance, Safeco Insurance (now Liberty Mutual), West Bend Insurance, Grange Insurance, Liberty Mutual Insurance, Progressive Insurance, Travelers Insurance
Already a customer?
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. customer service
- Make a payment
- Find billing and payment information for insurance carriers at https://www.isnerinsurance.com/billing-claims/ and manage premiums directly on the carrier's website.Foremost Insurance·The Hartford Insurance·National General Insurance·Safeco Insurance (now Liberty Mutual)·West Bend Insurance·Grange Insurance·Liberty Mutual Insurance·Progressive Insurance·Travelers Insurance
- Change a policy
- Policy changes and updates can be requested through the contact form or by calling (614) 236-8691.(614) 236-8691
- Certificates
- Certificates can be requested through the contact page, or eligible clients can use the self-service COI option to log in, add the certificate holder’s information, and download or email the certificate instantly.
- ID cards
- Request an ID card for an auto, boat, or motorcycle policy through the contact page.
- Coverage review
- Client portal
- Sign in to your account →
Reviews
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. reviews
Customers mention responsive and easy to reach, thorough and professional service, helps clients compare options and find better coverage or rates, trusted advice for home, auto, rental property, and business insurance and friendly, caring, and prompt customer service.
Our team
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. agents
FAQ
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. FAQ
Will my rate go up if I switch?
No. Getting a quote doesn't change your current policy or rate. Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. compares 9 carriers and shows you the options side by side. You only switch if a new policy saves you money or covers you better.
Do you charge a fee?
There is no charge to get a quote from Isner Insurance Associates, Inc.. Any fee on a specific policy is shown to you before you buy.
Is Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. independent?
Yes. Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. is an independent insurance agency, so it isn't tied to one company and can quote 9 carriers.
How do I get a quote?
Use the chat on this page, call (614) 236-8691 or visit the office at 3695 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214. It takes about 2 minutes and you don't need your Social Security number. Most quotes come back the site describes quotes and service as quick and says the team will reach out to complete the coverage comparison.
How do I file a claim?
Call your insurance company's claims line — the numbers are listed on this page under "Already a customer?". Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. can help you follow up at (614) 236-8691.
Who we are
About Isner Insurance Associates, Inc.
Recognition
- Licensed in
- OH
Ratings across sites
| 4.9(127) |