Twig created this listing from public information. It isn't managed by Penwell Insurance. Is this your agency?
Claim it
Penwell Insurance, Independent insurance agency in Carmel, IN
Licensed in IN, IL
Trusted independent insurance agency serving Carmel and Cicero, Indiana. Penwell Insurance helps individuals, families, and businesses compare coverage from multiple top-rated carriers for personal, life, and commercial insurance solutions tailored to their needs.
Contact info
- (317) 559-3022
- Carmel, IN
- penwellinsurance.com
Location & business hours
Business hours
- Sun
- Closed now
- Mon
- 9:00 AM–4:00 PM
- Tue
- 9:00 AM–4:00 PM
Carmel Office: Thu-Fri: By Appointment. Cicero Office: Available By Phone on Friday.
What do you need covered?
Quick answer
Penwell Insurance at a glance
Penwell Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Carmel, IN. It compares 6 carriers including Foremost Insurance, Hagerty Insurance and Erie Insurance for auto, home, renters and more.
- Agency type
- Independent — not tied to one insurance company
- Carriers compared
- 6 — Foremost Insurance, Hagerty Insurance, Erie Insurance, …
- Coverage
- 15 lines — auto, home, renters, condo, boat, …
- Licensed in
- IN, IL
- Serving
- Carmel, Cicero, Hamilton County, Indiana, Indiana, Illinois and Fishers
Getting a quote
How to get a quote from Penwell Insurance
How it works
- 1Use the secure quote request form.
- 2An instant auto/home quote is also available online.
Coverage we offer
Insurance coverage in Carmel, IN
Personal
Business
- Carriers
- Foremost Insurance, Hagerty Insurance, Erie Insurance (auto, home, business), The Progressive Corporation, Liberty Mutual Insurance, The Travelers Indemnity Company
Already a customer?
Penwell Insurance customer service
- Make a payment
- Online Billing & Payments is available at https://www.penwellinsurance.com/support/online-billing-payments/. Erie bill pay is available at https://www.erieinsurance.com/PaymentCenterWeb/BillPay/Payment/BillPayment?AgentNumber=FF1455&utm_source=bf_erieagents&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pay_bill_image&utm_content=penwellinsurance.comErie Insurance
- Change a policy
- Policy Change Request is available at https://www.penwellinsurance.com/support/policy-change-request/.(317) 559-3022
- Certificates
- Certificate of Insurance Request is available at https://www.penwellinsurance.com/support/certificate-of-insurance-request/.
- ID cards
- Auto ID Card Request is available at https://www.penwellinsurance.com/support/auto-id-card-request/.
- Coverage review
- Annual Insurance Checklist is available at https://www.penwellinsurance.com/support/annual-insurance-checklist/.
- Client portal
- Sign in to your account →
Visit us
Penwell Insurance offices
- Carmel Office600 E Carmel Drive Suite 162, Carmel, IN 46032Mon–Wed 9:00 AM–4:00 PM; Thu–Sun closedThu-Fri: By Appointment(317) 559-3022Directions →
- Cicero Office30 South Peru Street, Cicero, IN 46034Mon–Fri 9:00 AM–4:00 PM; Sat–Sun closedAvailable By Phone on Friday(317) 984-3300Directions →
FAQ
Penwell Insurance FAQ
Will my rate go up if I switch?
No. Getting a quote doesn't change your current policy or rate. Penwell Insurance compares 6 carriers and shows you the options side by side. You only switch if a new policy saves you money or covers you better.
Do you charge a fee?
There is no charge to get a quote from Penwell Insurance. Any fee on a specific policy is shown to you before you buy.
Is Penwell Insurance independent?
Yes. Penwell Insurance is an independent insurance agency, so it isn't tied to one company and can quote 6 carriers.
How do I get a quote?
Use the chat on this page, call (317) 559-3022 or visit the office at 600 E Carmel Drive Suite 162, Carmel, IN 46032. It takes about 2 minutes and you don't need your Social Security number.
How do I file a claim?
Call your insurance company's claims line — the numbers are listed on this page under "Already a customer?". Penwell Insurance can help you follow up at (317) 559-3022.
Who we are
About Penwell Insurance
Recognition
- Community
- Community Connection Program, Lights Over Morse Lake 2024 Concert Sponsors
- Licensed in
- IN, IL