No reviews yetCallView profile
Insurance agenciesList your agencyDirectory by Twig
Insurance agencies in Indiana
Twig lists 6 insurance agencies in Indiana. Each listing shows the agency's coverage, carriers and hours, with a 2-minute quote.
Updated Oct 21, 2026
Top-rated agencies in Indiana
6 agencies
2.Hoosier Insurance Agency
Independent agency · 18 carriers
Schererville, IN
- Auto
- Condo
- Homeowners
- Life
- +12 more
No reviews yetCallView profile3.Insurance Broker Direct
Independent agency · 15 carriers
Lafayette, IN
- Life
- Auto
- Homeowners
- Renters
- +11 more
No reviews yetCallView profile- No reviews yetCallView profile
5.Pilot Insurance Agency, Inc.
Independent agency · 24 carriers
Mishawaka, IN
- Homeowners
- Umbrella
- Renters
- Auto
- +7 more
No reviews yetCallView profile6.Shurr Insurance Agency
Independent agency · Since 1923 · 5 carriers
Valparaiso, IN
- Life
- Auto
- Homeowners
- E&O
- +9 more
No reviews yetCallView profile
Frequently asked questions
How many independent insurance agencies are in Indiana?
Twig lists 6 independent agencies in Indiana. Independent agencies compare quotes from several insurance companies; captive agencies represent one.
Which agencies in Indiana write business insurance?
5 of the listed agencies write commercial lines such as general liability, business owner's policies, workers' comp or commercial auto. Use the Coverage filter to see them.
How do I get a quote from a local agency?
Open any agency's page and choose Get a quote. Twig's assistant asks a few questions (about 2 minutes, no SSN) and the agency follows up, usually within one business day.
Cities in Indiana
How agencies are listed
Listings are built from each agency's website and public review sites. Agencies marked Verified have claimed their listing and keep it up to date. Ratings and review counts come from their sources. Results are sorted by rating, then by number of reviews.