Twig created this listing from public information. It isn't managed by Shurr Insurance Agency. Is this your agency?
Claim it
Shurr Insurance Agency, Independent insurance agency in Valparaiso, IN
Since 1923 · Licensed in IN, IL, MI, WI, OH, TN, MO, AZ, NV, FL, KY
5.0Independent insurance agency in Valparaiso serving personal, business, life, farm, trucking, and Medicare supplement insurance needs. The agency positions itself as trusted advisors who shop multiple carriers to balance price and protection and provide proactive service and claims support.
Contact info
Location & business hours
What do you need covered?
Hi, I'm JON, President & Commercial Risk Specialist of Shurr Insurance Agency. A licensed agent on my team reviews every quote. Meet JON →
Quick answer
Shurr Insurance Agency at a glance
Shurr Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Valparaiso, IN, founded in 1923. It compares 5 carriers including Auto Owners, First Mutual and Foremost for personal, business, life and more.
- Founded
- 1923 · 103 years in business
- Agency type
- Independent — not tied to one insurance company
- Carriers compared
- 5 — Auto Owners, First Mutual, Foremost, …
- Coverage
- 25 lines — personal, business, life, farm, trucking, …
- Licensed in
- IN, IL, MI, WI, OH, TN, MO, AZ, NV, FL, KY
- Serving
- Northwest Indiana, Northeast Illinois and Southwest Michigan
Getting a quote
How to get a quote from Shurr Insurance Agency
How it works
- 1Enter basic information on the website to start.
- 2The agency shops multiple insurance carriers for you.
- 3Choose the coverage package that fits best.
What to have ready
- Basic information
No Social Security number needed to start.
Coverage we offer
Insurance coverage in Valparaiso, IN
Personal
Business
- BusinessCommercial insurance for business owners of many sizes and industries.
- Farm
- Trucking
- Directors and OfficersLiability insurance intended to protect individuals from personal losses if they are sued as a result of serving as a director or officer of a business or organization. It can also cover legal fees and other costs the organization may incur.
- Contractors
- Business Owners (BOP)
- Professional Liability
- Commercial BuildingsCoverage for landlords and commercial real estate investors insuring buildings and habitation risks.
- Workers Compensation
- Commercial Auto
- Surety Bonds
- Businesses we insure
- Restaurants, Contractors, Manufacturing, Auto Services
- Carriers
- Auto Owners, First Mutual, Foremost, Hagerty, Metlife
Already a customer?
Shurr Insurance Agency customer service
Report a claim
Call your insurance company's claims line — open 24/7. Shurr Insurance Agency will help you follow up.
- Auto Owners(800) 288-8740
- First Mutual(919) 934-6111
- Foremost(800) 532-4221
- Hagerty(888) 220-9565
- Metlife(800) 638-5000
- Make a payment
- Clients can contact the agency, use the service center/client portal, or pay directly on carrier websites listed in the billing and claims directory.Auto Owners·First Mutual·Foremost·Hagerty·Metlife
- Change a policy
- Policy changes can be requested through the app, client portal, contact form, service center, or by calling or texting the agency.(219) 462-1146
- Certificates
- Certificates can be requested through the contact form, contact page, or service center.
- ID cards
- Clients can request ID cards through the contact form, by contacting the agency, or through the service center/client portal.
- Coverage review
- The agency proactively reviews policies at every renewal and can review your policy upon request.
- Client portal
- Sign in to your account →
- Your service team
- MEGAN SHURR-BUCZEK, Personal Lines Account Executive
- LISA WHITE, Commercial & Personal Lines Account Executive
- Shauna Brown, Personal Lines Account Executive & Claims Liaison
- Sherri Pozos, Client Service Representative
Reviews
Shurr Insurance Agency reviews
Customers mention responsive and proactive customer service., helpful guidance on coverage options and claims. and local, personal service with strong communication..
Our team
Shurr Insurance Agency agents
FAQ
Shurr Insurance Agency FAQ
Will my rate go up if I switch?
No. Getting a quote doesn't change your current policy or rate. Shurr Insurance Agency compares 5 carriers and shows you the options side by side. You only switch if a new policy saves you money or covers you better.
Do you charge a fee?
There is no charge to get a quote from Shurr Insurance Agency. Any fee on a specific policy is shown to you before you buy.
Is Shurr Insurance Agency independent?
Yes. Shurr Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency, so it isn't tied to one company and can quote 5 carriers.
How do I get a quote?
Use the chat on this page, call (219) 462-1146 or visit the office at 833 E. Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN 46383. It takes about 2 minutes and you don't need your Social Security number.
How do I file a claim?
Call your insurance company's claims line — the numbers are listed on this page under "Already a customer?". Shurr Insurance Agency can help you follow up at (219) 462-1146.
What happens if my insurance premium increases?
At each renewal the agency looks at your policy and checks it against carrier partners to make sure you are still getting the best deal, and will advise on the pros and cons of switching carriers.
What if I need to change something on my insurance?
You can request a change by downloading the app, visiting the client portal, or calling or texting (219) 462-1146.
I think I have a claim, now what?
The agency app provides the form for submitting a claim, walks you through what is needed, and sends the agency the necessary information.
What are all of the types of insurance you offer?
The agency offers home, life, rental, tenant, auto, umbrella, business owners/commercial, boats, ATVS, jewelry, personal property and more, and specializes in farm and business/commercial insurance.
I love the service I received; how do I refer you?
People can fill out a quote form on the website, receive a referral link from the app, or call the agency.
Who we are
About Shurr Insurance Agency
Recognition
- Community
- Members of the Valparaiso community.
- Licensed in
- IN, IL, MI, WI, OH, TN, MO, AZ, NV, FL, KY
Ratings across sites
| 5.0 |